Great Gray Owl perched in Teresa Wolfe’s yard with the title “Whose Voice Is Making This Decision?”

Whose Voice Is Making This Decision? | Teresa Wolfe

October 06, 2026•5 min read

YOUR BODY ALREADY KNOWS · PART 3

Have you ever stood in front of the refrigerator, reached for something to eat, and heard a running commentary in your head?

I shouldn’t eat that.

I need more protein.

Carbs are bad.

I already ate too much today.

I should eat this instead.

Most of us have accumulated quite a collection of ideas about food over the years. Some came from what we were taught. Some came from people we trust. Some came from our own experiences. And after we have heard or repeated them often enough, it can be difficult to remember where they came from.

So, when you make a decision about what to eat, whose voice is making that decision?

When a Thought Sounds Like Information

Sometimes the source is easy to recognize. A health professional may have recommended that you eat more—or less—of something. A coach may have suggested a particular food to improve your performance. You may have learned something about nutrition that changed the way you eat.

Then there are the messages we absorb simply by living in the world. Food trends change. Headlines contradict each other. Friends and family have opinions. Social media adds another steady stream of advice about what we should and shouldn’t eat.

Some of that information may be useful. Some may have been useful at one time and less useful now. Some may be well supported by science, and some may not be.

The interesting part is what happens after a message has been repeated often enough.

I shouldn’t be hungry yet.

I was bad today.

I need to finish this.

I can’t control myself around that food.

This is healthier, so this is what I should eat.

Those thoughts can become so familiar that we barely notice them as thoughts anymore.

This is where the distinction we have been exploring in the Your Body Already Knows series becomes particularly useful: your body provides information. Making sense of that information requires discernment.

Hunger is information. Fullness is information. Energy, digestion, comfort and how you feel after eating are information. Our bodies have extensive systems for detecting and communicating internal physiological conditions. Scientists use the term interoception to describe the process by which the nervous system senses, interprets and integrates signals originating within the body.

But what we say about that information is something else.

“I’m hungry” and “I shouldn’t be hungry” are not the same kind of information. The first describes an experience. The second adds an interpretation. And where did that interpretation come from?

I’ve Been Asking This Question for a Long Time

I have been interested in the voices influencing our food choices for years.

Back in 2024, I wrote about negative self-talk around food—the familiar “I shouldn’t eat this” kind of commentary that can become part of our everyday eating. Then, as I began 2025, I asked an even broader question: Who—or What—is Driving Your Food Story?

At the time, I was exploring the many ways our experiences, habits, culture and beliefs can become part of our relationship with food. I’m returning to that question now because I see another distinction that I think is important. The information coming from your body and the conversation going on in your head about that information are not necessarily the same thing.

That distinction may seem small, but think about how quickly the two can become tangled together.

When Experience and Expectation Collide

Last week, in When Eating Healthy Starts to Feel “Off”, we explored what can happen when nutrition information and our actual experience don’t seem to line up.

There may be another layer to consider. Sometimes the conflict isn’t between our body and nutrition science at all. It may be between what we are experiencing and what we have come to believe that experience is supposed to mean.

Research on interoception supports a more complex picture than simply “listen to your body.” Internal bodily signals are interpreted within the brain and integrated with previous experience and information from our environment. That is one reason I think it is more accurate to treat what we experience in our bodies as information rather than as an unquestionable instruction. Read more about interoception in this NIH-indexed review.

You might notice that you are hungry and hear, But I just ate.

You might be comfortably full and hear, There are only three bites left.

You might genuinely enjoy a food and immediately think, I shouldn’t have eaten that.

Or you may choose something because you understand it to be healthy, even though your experience with it repeatedly leaves you wondering whether it works particularly well for you.

None of those moments necessarily tells you what to do next. They simply give you more information to work with.

Whose Voice Is It?

Perhaps you know immediately where a particular thought came from.

Perhaps you don’t.

You may even discover that several voices are contributing to the same decision. What you know about nutrition may be there. So may your previous experience, something someone once told you, a concern about your health, an old expectation, your current circumstances—and the information coming from your body right now.

That doesn’t automatically make any one of those voices right or wrong. It does make the decision more interesting.

And it may help explain why deciding what to eat can sometimes feel considerably more complicated than simply asking, What am I hungry for?

An Ordinary Place to Notice

This is one reason I continue to find our relationship with food so fascinating. We make food decisions several times a day, and tucked inside those ordinary decisions are our knowledge, histories, experiences, habits, relationships and beliefs.

We don’t necessarily have to sort all of that out every time we make lunch. But every once in a while, when a familiar thought pops into your head about what you should eat, shouldn’t eat, ought to want or shouldn’t be feeling, it might be interesting simply to notice it.

Huh. Where did that come from?

Sometimes a question is enough to show us something we hadn’t noticed before. And sometimes it leaves us curious enough to look a little deeper.

If this has you wondering about some of the voices, habits and patterns influencing your own eating, my free Genuinely Fed Nourishment Starter Kit gives you a practical place to explore them.

Get the Genuinely Fed Nourishment Starter Kit

Because how we eat reflects how we live.


Back to Blog