
When Eating Healthy Starts to Feel “Off” | Teresa Wolfe
YOUR BODY ALREADY KNOWS · PART 2
By most measures, you’re eating pretty well.
Yet…
…something feels off.
Maybe you’re hungry again an hour later. Your energy is dragging by mid-afternoon. Your digestion has changed. You finish a meal that checked all the “healthy” boxes and and afterward, you just don’t feel quite right.
Now what?
That can be an uncomfortable place to be—especially when you’ve been genuinely trying to take good care of yourself.
Noticing that something feels “off” doesn’t mean that either the nutrition advice you have received or your experience is necessarily wrong. In fact, nutrition science can tell us a great deal about foods, nutrients, health and the patterns we see across populations. Your own experience can tell you what happened when you ate that particular food, in that amount, under those particular circumstances, on that particular day.
“Off” Is Where the Questions Begin
Suppose you’ve started eating a particular breakfast because it fits with what you understand about healthy eating. But you begin noticing that you’re hungry again much sooner than you expected.
Huh.
What’s happening here?
Maybe it happened once. Maybe you begin noticing it more often. Perhaps you find yourself wondering about the breakfast itself, how much you ate, what the rest of your morning looked like, how active you were, how you slept—or something you haven’t thought of yet.
You might become curious about the protein, fiber or overall energy in the meal. What if you change something, just to notice what happens? Perhaps the pattern disappears. Perhaps it doesn’t. Maybe what you notice eventually seems worthy of more investigation.
If you can resist looking for a quick explanation, the experience gives you something to work with.
Here is where the science geek side of me gets really excited. You have data - what you know about nutrition, what you are experiencing, and the circumstances surrounding it. And you can continue gathering information.
Instead of requiring either an outside authority or a single experience to provide the answer, you can lean into the moment a bit deeper. You can consider the different sources of information and decide what makes sense.
A Bigger Question in the News
We can ask experts, search the internet, follow influencers or ask AI and have an answer in seconds. The harder part is deciding accurately what applies, what deserves our trust and what we will do with it.
Recently, I read that former New York Times journalist David Brooks has launched a podcast called The Permanent Questions, turning his attention to what he calls the “really big questions of life.” His first conversation began with one of the most fundamental queries: How should we live our lives?
There are some aspects of basic questions like this no one else can answer for us. That said, food—and our relationship to it—gives us a surprisingly ordinary place to practice finding answers to the deeper questions of our life. This is why I am so passionate about what I do. We can learn so much about ourselves just by noticing our relationship with what we eat, our eating behaviors - aka, how we nourish ourselves.
An Everyday Place to Practice
We eat every day.
Every meal gives us an opportunity to notice how we respond—not only to what we eat, but to how, when and under what circumstances we eat. The feedback can come quickly, and over time patterns emerge.Maybe the pattern you’ve noticed is worthy of more investigation.
That makes eating a kind of everyday practice ground for noticing without judgment.
What’s happening here? Am I seeing a pattern? What else might I want to know before I decide what this means?
There is no single correct question. There may not even be an answer yet. But each experience gives us another opportunity to notice what happens and learn from it.
A small change may make a big difference. Or not. New information can change how you understand what happened. Something that initially seemed confusing may begin to make more sense.
What if learning from these small experiences with food also helps us become a little more comfortable when the answer isn’t immediately obvious? What if we can consider what we know, pay attention to our experience, keep asking questions—and gradually become more confident in our own judgment?
And with every meal, we get another chance to learn.
How cool is that?
Because how we eat reflects how we live.
I would love to know…
What have you learned from paying attention to your own experience with food? I’d love to hear your thoughts in the comments.
